I like warnings. I used to need warnings more than I currently do, but I appreciate knowing I'll need to put myself into a more guarded frame of mind to read a story that will push my safety zones.
You may say profic doesn't come with warnings, but I disagree. If it says "horror" on the book jacket, and if the blurb on the back has words like "survivor", "graphic", "violent", "devastating", "ordeal", "brutal", or "harrowing", then we've been warned. Also, there's the genre issue: most fanfic tends to be romance. We don't expect violent deathfic in the midst of a dozen fluffy romance stories. (Conversely, we don't expect Stephen King to write a fluffy romance -- so if you brand yourself an author of one thing and then deliver the polar opposite, you can expect some surprise on the part of your readers.)
But back to my point, yes, I can always click the back button or close the book, but it's a
human need to find out how a story ends, and a story that resolves with the hero or heroine working through their trauma and healing offers vicarious healing to the reader.
The Lord of the Rings is a harrowing quest with an ultimately happy ending. No one's the same by the end, but the story is worth it because the process the characters go through -- growing and rising to the challenge -- outweighs the terrors of the journey.
I push my safety zones because exposure training is how you overcome terror of a thing. (If you fear cockroaches, you can overcome it by slowly reading about them, looking at photos, and eventually being in the same room as one and then killing it). Looking at abusive behavior in other contexts, like fanfic, is a tool for healing abuse trauma, especially if the survivor has a qualified therapist to work through her issues with. But it requires the survivor to emotionally prepare herself.
A good portion of my PTSD is the doing of someone whom I could but won't link to. Blame the attacker. If you blame me, then all you do is ally yourself with him, alienate me, and prove yourself a complete asshat. You're a better person than that, right? I want to believe you are because I'm in fandom for the awesome people, not just the stories.
And women are as awesome as we want to be, yes? Yes.
However, attacking women
because they were attacked and now are in the process of healing
supports misogyny. Telling a woman to "get over it" is ONLY the place of her most trusted advisors who know the depth of her grief and the extent of her healing process. From anyone else, it's unutterably rude and condescending, and there's enough misogyny in the world without women adding to it by degrading each other.
But.
I admit I don't always warn. I've grown tolerant of a lot of things that other readers find triggery, and it just doesn't occur to me. Also, I don't think offscreen trauma needs a warning, usually. At times I use a blanket warning of: "This fic includes some disturbing content." I like that because it preserves the mystery of the plot
and allows sensitive readers to ask a friend to preread for them. (I have frequently asked friends to preread for me. It's the difference between a panic attack and enjoying a good story, so I find it worth the trouble of asking for the favor.)
Also, sometimes I don't realize I should warn because when I've been living inside a fic for however long it's taken me to write it, I'm not affected by the triggery issues -- at least not in the way the way a reader is. Failing to warn in that case is an error on my part. But, when someone points out to me that they wish I'd put in a warning for x, I apologize and go back and add it. That is the best I can do at that point, and I'll gladly do it. It's like putting in a stoplight at an intersection where there's been an accident. You don't realize there's a need until it's too late, but at that point the need is clear and putting in a light will save others from harm. That's common decency. Refusing to warn when it's clearly needed is sadistic; over-warning when it isn't necessary is patronizing.
In short: reasonable measures are reasonable.
Other issues:
People in the throes of a PTSD flashback or panic attack are freaking out. They aren't focused on being polite or nice. They're in distress and may lash out from a place of distress. (Been there, done that; there's a reason the first few years of my journal are locked private.) It's ugly, raw, and emotional, and logic doesn't hold a candle against that level of distress. Compassion, otoh, does.
Some people are drama-mongers. There are always a few. I choose to believe they don't know any better (and their need for therapy/enlightenment is their own responsibility), so I try to answer civilly before I step far, far away for my own mental health.
"It only takes an extra second to be courteous," says Fraser. I love Due South fandom in part because "courtesy" is the fandom's watchword. This is the peace we've achieved in the wake of some ugly, ugly ship wars: be nice, be civil about both Rays, have fun.
That's my response to practically every kerfuffle these days:
be nice, be civil about x, have fun. Being civil about warnings is easy. Use a blanket (and vague) disturbing content warning like TV shows do. Or use the blackout code. Or state in the header that you don't believe in warnings. That's a warning in itself, and if I see that then I'll skip to the comments, find someone who's read the fic, and ask them if any of my squicks are in the fic. I will take the extra moment to take responsibility for my mental health. To do that, though, I need the notification at the top that I'm going to need to do so.
Note: I appreciate it when reccers offer warnings with their recs. "Disturbing content, but worth it!" goes a long way with me. *g*
Okay, I'm going to be out of pocket for a while today, so there might be a delay in answering comments but I'll get there. Peace, y'all. It's a gorgeous, sunny (if too hot) day here. I hope everyone finds something beautiful around them to enjoy. <3